With two officers and a sergeant, Helmetta's police department lacks enough manpower to serve the borough.
In a borough of only 2,200 residents, Helmetta's three-person police force has long been a revolving door.
Officers frequently join the department directly from the police academy or while they're still attending, and the force's small size leaves little room for career development, Mayor Christopher Slavicek said. Combine that with salary restrictions, he said, and officers often quickly leave for nearby towns.
"You're not going to hold somebody back from wanting to better themselves in the police world," Slavicek said Friday.
Those staffing challenges have forced Helmetta to seek to disband its police department, which is one of the smallest in New Jersey. Two officers and a sergeant currently patrol the borough, and the chief is on medical leave.
The borough council is expected to vote April 18 to eradicate the force and enter into a shared services agreement with neighboring Spotswood or Jamesburg.
The move would mirror the footsteps of other municipalities, like Fieldsboro and Lake Como, that have gotten rid of their small police departments in favor of having another municipality assume those services at a lower cost.
Helmetta's three officers have been given layoff notices, Slavicek said. He said Spotswood police, which shares a PBA union with Helmetta, was working with the laid-off officers to help them find other jobs.
The borough's police equipment and vehicles will be auctioned, Slavicek said.
The Middlesex County Prosecutor's Office for more than a year had been providing two supervisors to oversee Helmetta's officers, but notified the borough last year that it would not continue to do so.
In a letter to Slavicek in August, Prosecutor Andrew Carey said Helmetta's police department historically "has been in various stages of turmoil." The force lacks enough patrol officers, has no specialized officers or administrative staff, and fails to have sufficient written policies and procedures, Carey wrote.
The department also doesn't have the infrastructure it needs, including dashboard cameras, body-worn cameras and tasers, the letter said. It said Helmetta's officers are often unavailable to attend mandatory, in-service trainings.
"The HPD currently relies heavily on surrounding towns for basic police functions," Carey wrote. "... Consolidation with a nearby town is clearly the next logical step."
Borough officials this month sent a letter to 1,088 households saying Helmetta planned to seek shared services with Spotswood or Jamesburg and asking for residents' opinions. Modernizing Helmetta's department to meet mandated police training standards and staffing would result in significant tax increases, officials said in the letter.
Roughly 75 percent of residents who responded said they preferred to share a police force with Spotswood, which Slavicek said already has "a quasi-marriage" with Helmetta. The two municipalities share EMS services and trash removal, while Helmetta students attend Spotswood schools.
Slavicek said continuing to allow only three police officers to serve Helmetta would be a disservice to residents' safety and fiscally irresponsible. At a cost of more than $800,000 in 2017, police services are the borough's largest budget item.
Slavicek said he and the borough's public safety committee didn't want to have to disband the police department, but concluded it was in Helmetta's best interest.
"You have to think with your head and not your heart, unfortunately," he said.
Yvette Bruno, who has lived in Helmetta since 1990 and served on the council in 2014, said the borough has been trying to improve its police services for as long as she can remember.
"In all honesty, it's about time, and it's really been in the making for many years," she said. "Small towns really need to merge with the bigger towns."
Marisa Iati may be reached at miati@njadvancemedia.com. Follow her on Twitter @Marisa_Iati or on Facebook here. Find NJ.com on Facebook.
Have a tip? Tell us. nj.com/tips