The campaign mailers sent last year targeting two minority candidates, stamped "Deport," led to worldwide coverage but we still don't know who sent the fliers.
The fliers landed in mailboxes around the township less than a week before Election Day, carrying racist attacks and pledging to "Make Edison Great Again!"
"The Chinese and Indians are taking over our town!" the fliers said. On one side were pictures of candidates for the local, non-partisan school board, Jerry Shi and Falguni Patel, stamped with the word "Deport."
The bald bigotry of anonymous campaign mailers targeting two minority candidates in the state's fifth-largest town -- known for its ethnic diversity and its tumultuous municipal politics-- lit a firestorm in the local campaign and drew media coverage from around the globe.
The international attention quickly subsided when Shi and Patel won seats on the local school board despite the racist smears. But since last year, the lingering question of who sent the fliers has fueled whispered speculation among the township's political class as formal investigations quietly bounced between local, state and federal law enforcement.
Many saw the fliers as a xenophobic attack on minority groups by those seeking to uphold the status quo. Others quietly harbored suspicion it was a calculated move to rally Indian and East Asian voters and boost candidates backed by the town's powerful local Democratic party.
Now, the town council is being asked to pen a resolution calling on Attorney General Gurbir Grewal's office to investigate the mailers, according to an email from a former mayoral candidate, Keith Hahn, sent to all township employees and obtained by NJ Advance Media.
But NJ Advance Media has learned the Attorney General's Office has already been quietly investigating for months, identifying at least one person of interest but no clear suspects.
Two sources with knowledge of the matter who spoke under condition of anonymity told the news outlet that investigators at the Division of Criminal Justice's bias crimes unit were trying track the origin of the stamps used on the fliers, enlisting the help of the U.S. Postal Inspection Service.
Joe Blaetler -- a private investigator who said he was hired by a law firm, which he declined to name, to look into the source of the mailers -- told the news outlet state investigators interviewed him and confirmed they had connected the stamps to a suspect. They did not identify the person, he said.
It is still unclear, however, what crime, if any, was committed in sending out the fliers. Depending on a range of factors - including who paid for them, for what purpose and how many were sent, the total of which was unknown - the offense could range from criminal charges to civil campaign violations, the sources said.
Peter Aseltine, a spokesman for the attorney general, said he could "neither confirm nor deny" the existence of an investigation by his office. A spokesman for the New Jersey Election Law Enforcement Commission also declined to comment on whether his agency was investigating.
More than nine months after the controversy roiled the Middlesex County town, private debates over the mailers are expected to bubble over into public view on Wednesday evening at the town council meeting.
Hahn, the former chairman of the town Democratic party who ran unsuccessfully for mayor as a Republican after a primary loss, has been taking to social media to push for the resolution as a "sign of solidarity." Hahn has called on Edison's Democratic mayor, Thomas Lankey, as well as the local party leaders -- Democratic Chairman Shariq Ahmad and Republican Chairwoman Sylvia Engle -- to publicly support the calls for an investigation.
Lankey declined to comment on the email from Hahn. When the fliers originally made news, the mayor denounced them and called on his administration to do everything to expose who was behind the mailers.
Hahn, an Edison police officer, said he was interviewed by state investigators two months ago and sat down with local authorities in the initial stages of the case.
The two candidates on the mailers - Shi, who is Chinese-American, and Patel, who is Indian-American - said they had no knowledge of who sent them.
"If I knew who sent the fliers we would not be here," said Shi, who confirmed he was contacted by state investigators but would not say whether he spoke with local authorities previously.
"Let's let their investigation go," he said.
Two law enforcement sources say Shi refused to meet with Edison authorities or the Postal Inspector, who was also involved in the early stages of the investigation.
Patel confirmed she had been interviewed by authorities but declined to comment further, saying she didn't want to interfere with the investigation.
"I hope that they do find whoever it is that was part of this," she said.
Two sources said in the days leading up to the election, she confided in friends that the fliers were particularly troubling because the photo of her came from her personal Facebook page and had privacy settings that would only make it available to those in her friend network.
Patel met with Edison police, who initially handled the case, in the days after the fliers were sent and later agreed to be interviewed by state investigators who visited her home earlier this year, according to the two sources.
Ahmad -- who took over as Edison Democratic Chairman last year after a filing flap involving Hahn, now a registered Republican -- said he's had no contact with the Attorney General's Office but has kept tabs on the case through his local connections.
He declined to comment on whether or not he'd spoken with local investigators, saying the case was ongoing.
Engel said she had no knowledge of who sent the fliers and denounced the mailer's message, saying, even though her party supported the opposing ticket, Patel and Shi had an "absolute right to run."
The local Republican leader said she has not been contacted by state or township authorities.
Craig McCarthy may be reached at 732-372-2078 or at CMcCarthy@njadvancemedia.com. Follow him on Twitter @createcraig and on Facebook here.
S.P. Sullivan may be reached at ssullivan@njadvancemedia.com.
Have a tip? Tell us.
nj.com/tips