Supporters say without an ID, individuals often cannot open a bank account or access government services. Detractors argue it will "incentivize lawbreaking."
A growing number of New Jersey municipalities are issuing identification cards to unauthorized immigrants. NJ.com users posted more than 400 comments debating in favor and against the practice.
Union County's Roselle is about to become the latest town to offer municipal ID cards. Newark recently adopted the cards, while Perth Amboy, Highland Park and other New Jersey communities are in various stages of consideration. Asbury Park, Trenton, Freehold and Mercer and Morris counties are among other places in the state that have endorsed or issue the cards.
We solicited full responses from readers with opposing views. Here's what two NJ.com users had to say (edited for clarity):
The strongest argument for issuing ID cards is the benefit that foreign undocumented workers bring to the local economy. They need housing, groceries, cars, public transportation and all the other services that people need. According to the US Treasury, immigrants are far more likely to start new businesses and create jobs for others. Often times, undocumented immigrants will perform jobs that Americans don't want -- so-called "stoop labor." That benefits farmers. This country was built by immigrants.
Enrique Lavin may be reached at elavin@njadvancemedia.com. Follow him on Twitter @enriquelavin or on Facebook. Follow NJ.com Politics on Facebook.