Jahmmel Cephas is accused of fatally shooting aspiring youth mentor Richard Pryce in Perth Amboy in 2015.
NEW BRUNSWICK -- A trial continued Tuesday for a 35-year-old Franklin Park man accused of fatally shooting an aspiring youth mentor in Perth Amboy in 2015.
On the early morning of Feb. 14, 2015, Jahmmel Cephas stood over 31-year-old Richard Pryce, who had already been shot twice, and fatally shot him in the chest, prosecutors said. Cephas' attorney, however, has argued that Pryce brutally attacked Cephas, leaving him no choice but to defend himself.
Cephas was charged with murder 10 days after the shooting and was arrested three weeks later in Georgia by the U.S. Marshals Service.
During opening statements Thursday before Judge Colleen Flynn in New Brunswick, Assistant Prosecutor Christopher Dize said Pryce attended a surprise birthday party for a friend's wife that day at the 829 Lounge in Perth Amboy.
Richard Pryce (Photo provided by family)
About 1:30 a.m., Cephas showed up to the club and got in an argument with Pryce over Pryce's girlfriend, Dize said. The two fought and Pryce was kicked out of the club, the assistant prosecutor said.
A minute later, Cephas left and followed Pryce down Barclay Street from Amboy Avenue, Dize said. Pryce saw him out of the corner of his eye and turned around as Cephas pulled an illegally possessed 9-mm handgun out of waistband and pointed it at Pryce, prosecutors said.
"What're you going to do with that?" Pryce, who was unarmed, asked Cephas, according to Dize.
"The defendant answers by pulling the trigger," Dize said.
Cephas continued to shoot as Pryce charged him, Diez said. Five shots later, Pryce was lying on the ground on his back with two gunshot wounds to his right leg. He put his arms up to surrender, prosecutors said.
"Yo, yo," Pryce told Cephas as he stood over him with the gun, Dize said. "That's it."
Cephas then shot Pryce in the chest, breaking a rib and severing an artery, Dize said. The bullet exited his back.
The defendant ran as witnesses stared "frozen in shock" at Pryce, Dize said. Pryce then stood up and ran to the club, where his friends drove him to the Raritan Bay Medical Center.
They carried him into the emergency room and Pryce told doctors he could not breathe, Dize said. Emergency personnel put multiple IV tubes in him and unsuccessfully performed CPR after he lost consciousness, the assistant prosecutor said.
Pryce was pronounced dead at the hospital, just blocks from the Raritan Bay Area YMCA where he often volunteered, friends said.
Cephas never intended to fight Pryce with his fists, Dize said.
"Why else would you bring a handgun to a fistfight?" he asked the jurors.
About a month later, Cephas was arrested without incident at a barber shop in Lithonia, Ga., a suburb outside Atlanta, the U.S. Marshals Service said.
Jahmmel Cephas (Photo provided by authorities)
Prosecutors plan to show jurors surveillance video from inside the club and on the street, Dize said. The state will also call people who witnessed the shooting to the stand, as well as experts who say they discovered DNA from Cephas and Pryce on the defendant's hat left at the scene.
Cephas' attorney, Caroline Bielak, told the story differently.
Bielak said Pryce approached Cephas before the fight at the club. Once the lounge closed, Cephas walked home and turned down Barclay Street when Pryce rushed at him, she said.
The defendant fired multiple warning shots at the ground in self-defense, she said.
"He could not get away, Richard Pryce just kept coming," Bielak told the jurors. "Ladies and gentleman, this is a case of self-defense."
Pryce grabbed Cephas and pulled him to the ground, attacking him, Bielak said. During the fight, more shots were fired and Pryce was struck in the chest, she said.
When Pryce ran back to the club, Cephas did not try to stop him or take another shot, his attorney said.
"He just wanted to get away," Bielak said of Cephas. "This is a sad case, there's no way around that. It's a sad case because ... Jahmmel Cephas had no choice."
Prosecutors said Cephas has ties to the Bloods 36th Street and a criminal record dating back to 1998.
Court documents show that by 26, Cephas had multiple convictions for crimes including aggravated assault, criminal trespass and possession of a controlled dangerous substance with intent to distribute.
In previous interviews, friends and family remembered Pryce, the son of Jamaican immigrants, as meticulous, passionate and encouraging. He "wanted to see the best in you," his childhood friend, Ray Santiago, told NJ Advance Media in 2015.
"I know that recently, he had a strong passion about helping the community, especially young men like him," Santiago said. "That's why it's been especially painful in recent days for those close to him, because he was outspoken against this same sort of violence."
Luke Nozicka can be reached at lnozicka@njadvancemedia.com or on Twitter @lukenozicka.
Find NJ.com on Facebook and Twitter.